NSE Index Showdown: Strategy vs Sectoral vs Thematic vs Broad Market
The Indian stock market, represented by the National Stock Exchange (NSE), offers a diverse array of investment opportunities through its various indices. This comprehensive analysis delves into the performance of different NSE indices across multiple timeframes, focusing on returns, volatility, and investment strategies. By examining the data presented in the image above, we can extract valuable insights for investors looking to optimize their portfolios.
1. The Dominance of Strategy-based Indices
One of the most striking observations from the data is the consistent outperformance of strategy-based indices. The NIFTY MID150_M50 stands out as a top performer, boasting impressive returns across all timeframes:
- 1-year rolling return: 22.99%
- 3-year rolling return: 21.06%
- 5-year rolling return: 23.13%
- 7-year rolling return: 23.05%
This index, along with others like NIFTY MIDSMALL400_MQ100 (21.11% 1-year return) and NIFTYSMALL250_MQ100 (19.73% 1-year return), demonstrates the potential benefits of strategic stock selection within the mid and small-cap segments.
2. The Risk-Return Tradeoff
As we examine the scatter plots of returns versus volatility, a clear pattern emerges. Generally, higher returns are associated with higher volatility. However, this relationship isn’t perfectly linear, suggesting opportunities for optimizing risk-adjusted returns.
The plots show that strategy-based indices (represented by blue circles) tend to cluster in the upper-left quadrant, indicating higher returns with moderate volatility. Sectoral indices (green circles) show a wider spread, reflecting the varying risk-return profiles of different sectors.
3. Market Cap Dynamics
The data reveals an interesting trend related to market capitalization. Mid-cap and small-cap focused indices tend to outperform their large-cap counterparts across most timeframes. This is evident in the superior performance of indices like NIFTY MID150_M50 and NIFTY MIDSMALL400_MQ100 compared to the broader NIFTY50 or NIFTY100 indices.
For instance, in the 7-year time frame:
- NIFTY_MIDCAP150 shows a return of 16.08%
- NIFTY_MIDSMALL400 shows a return of 14.97%
- In contrast, NIFTY50 shows a return of 11.93%
This trend is consistent across 3-year and 5-year timeframes as well, suggesting a persistent outperformance of mid and small-cap strategies.
4. Sector-specific Performance
Sectoral indices show varied performance. Some sectors, like NIFTY_CONSDURABLE (19.62% 1-year return) and NIFTY_FINSRVCS-EXBANK (18.13% 1-year return), demonstrate strong returns, particularly in the shorter timeframes.
However, sectors like NIFTY_REALTY and NIFTY_METAL exhibit high volatility (39.71% and 33.85% respectively) and significant drawdowns (-92.77% and -78.06% max drawdown respectively), highlighting the importance of sector selection in portfolio construction.
5. The Resilience of Low Volatility Strategies
The scatter plot clearly shows how strategy-based indices (light green dots) tend to cluster towards the top-left, indicating higher returns with lower volatility compared to market indices (red dots).
6. The Underperformance of Certain Thematic Indices
While some thematic indices like NIFTY_MNC show promise (14.81% 7-year return), others like NIFTY_Infrastructure (3.93% 7-year return) and NIFTY_PSE (Public Sector Enterprises, 4.77% 7-year return) consistently underperform. This underscores the importance of careful selection when considering thematic investments.
7. Long-term Perspective
The 7-year return data provides valuable insights into long-term performance. Strategy-based indices continue to dominate, with many showing returns above 20% over this extended period. This suggests that well-designed investment strategies can deliver superior returns over longer horizons.
Conclusion:
This in-depth analysis of NSE indices reveals several key takeaways for investors:
1. Strategy-based indices, particularly those focused on mid and small-caps, have shown superior performance across multiple timeframes.
2. While higher returns often come with higher volatility, there are opportunities to optimize risk-adjusted returns, as demonstrated by the clustering of strategy-based indices in the scatter plots.
3. Careful sector and theme selection is crucial, as performance varies significantly across different market segments.
As always, investors should consider their risk tolerance and investment goals when making decisions. Past performance doesn’t guarantee future results, but understanding these trends can help inform more robust investment strategies in the dynamic Indian stock market.
Watch detailed YouTube videos here :
Part 1:
Part 2:
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
QuantX-Builder for Mastering Momentum Investing. 4 week comprehensive learning programme.
bit.ly/QuantX-MomentumLAB
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — —
Important Links
Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MomentumLab_IN
Twitter: https://x.com/MomentumLab_IN